Aaron M. Renn

All Things Aaron

  • Home
  • Bio
  • Press
  • Archives
    • By Date
    • By City
    • Podcasts
    • Reviews
    • Articles in City Journal
    • Articles in the Guardian
    • Articles in Governing Magazine
    • Articles in New Geography
  • Get Posts By Email
  • Get Posts by RSS
  • Podcast

Globalization’s Winner Take All Economy

January 10, 2017 By Aaron M. Renn

Cincinnati image via Shutterstock

Globalization and technology aren’t just producing divergence in outcomes between the highly educated and the lesser educated, but within the higher skill, higher value portion of the economy it is also disproportionately rewarding superstar performers. This secondary divide is one less talked about, but it’s the subject of my column in the January issue of Governing magazine.

Economist Richard Florida calls this phenomenon “winner-take-all urbanism.” It’s the superstar athlete or celebrity effect transposed into the urban world. Just as A-list stars earn far more than the merely famous, the top business talent and the top cities are reaping disproportionate riches over the merely prosperous.

This divide is harder to spot because the people and places involved are often superficially similar. The people in both possess university degrees. They share similar cultural norms, aspirations and politics. The places they live in all have their farm-to-table restaurants, tech startups, artisanal coffee roasters and bicycle commuter infrastructure. As with a sports team, they all wear the same uniform. But some are all-stars while others are role players who are more easily replaced.

When young workers or artists struggle to find an affordable apartment in a global capital, this isn’t just proof of a failure to deregulate housing development. It’s also a marketplace sending a powerful signal that their position among the winners of society is much more precarious than they might imagine. Most would agree that there are some businesses and people who shouldn’t be in New York or San Francisco. We shouldn’t expect a peanut butter spread of talent and economic activity across the country. The nature of the industries concentrated in these places produces a higher-end specialization. So there will be some economic value line below which it isn’t viable to be there.

Click through to read the whole thing.

My argument is that there are people who have labeled themselves “winners” in the new economy who may successful in a sense, but are much more at risk from the current system than they might want to think.

Share This Post:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

Related

Filed Under: Demographics and Economic Development

Comments

  1. Robert Cook says

    January 10, 2017 at 6:28 pm

    So the question, what can be done about. Anything? After all, politically and socially, there are still going to be plenty of people in loserville. Most people, actually.

  2. Michael R. says

    January 10, 2017 at 9:03 pm

    It’s like I told people before the election, it doesn’t matter who you vote for, we as a country have not dealt with globalism. It’s neither good nor evil,it’s not going away and as Aaron has shown in his article can have unexpected consequences even if you think you’re one of the winners.

Get my eBook The Urban State of Mind for your Kindle from Amazon.

Get a free PDF version by signing up for free, exclusive articles and newsletters - because you don't want to miss anything.


Listen via iTunes | Soundcloud

About Aaron M. Renn


 
Aaron M. Renn is a Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute and an opinion-leading urban analyst, writer, and speaker on a mission to help America’s cities thrive and find sustainable success in the 21st century. (Photo Credit: Daniel Axler)
 
Email: aaron@aaronrenn.com
Full Bio

Trending Posts

  • Don't Fall in the Branding Trap
  • Nine Reasons Why Detroit Failed
  • Facing Tough Facts in Louisville
  • President Pete?

Disclosures

Links on this site may contain embedded “affiliate codes.” Purchases made through these links may result in a payment to me.
 
Header design by Carl Wohlt.
Header images via Shutterstock.

Copyright © 2006-2019 Urbanophile, LLC, All Rights Reserved - Click here for copyright information and disclosures