Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tom's avatar
2dEdited

A few thoughts:

1. This essay reads like it was written with a lot of help from AI. At the very least, the syntax and diction is very reminiscent of it.

2. The so-called "infinite economy" isn't. Energy acquisition, transmission, and storage capacity are all limited, to say nothing of server capacity, and we can choose whether or not to build and channel that capacity towards AI. Which brings up my third thought...

3. Is this actually inevitable, or is this a future that we can choose to avoid? As has been proven time and again, when people are left idle--and this is as true of aristocrats as it is peasants--they rarely end up choosing to pursue the good, true, and beautiful, because that is not mankind's natural tendency. I am not confident that this future is not one where the primary job fields are AI checker, home caregiver, construction worker, cop, and "creative," and I don't think that future ends well. The market was made for man, not man for the market.

William Abbott's avatar

Very insightful, very interesting, probably correct on balance about the autonomous participation of "agents." Infinite economy is a good moniker.

But what about the prophets? What about human voices crying in the wilderness about Truth and the Kingdom of Heaven? Renn thinks Charlie Kirk, whatever he was, was a poor example of the Evangelical Elite. He wants Evangelical elites fully participating in governance. Fully vested in the "system" that rules over us. Kirk was a prophet. Christ is King and the University is dead. "Don't go to college!" Where in the brave new world of autonomous machine agency will we find our prophets?

The agency of surveillance is at hand. How is that going to work? How are the autonomous killing machines of war and law enforcement going to be controlled? What has changed that man will no longer practice war or compete for power? We have always failed the test when tempted at: 'The Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil' What has changed? Why will we finally say 'yes' to God?

Why will women enter into a life of sacrifice and servitude to their families? Why will they suddenly decide to start bearing children for their husbands? The global TFR has already crashed and burned. Infinite economy is not going to coax the fairer sex into biological sacrifice. They will say, "I'd rather not".

We will become less human and more like our agency servants. Never concerned about Truth. Living for just a little more Mammon.

8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?