Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Paul Perrone's avatar

Again, George Orwell’s (my favorite atheist) quote comes to mind when I read these twisted arguments against marriage and fatherhood, “Some things are so stupid that only intellectuals believe them.” The book, “The Faith of the Fatherless” by Paul Vitz is a great resource on this issue and I have recommended it to many fathers.

But a quick story about the young women I encountered. After I retired from the Army I worked many years as a program manager for a medium-sized government contractor in support of DoD. We enjoyed a lot of success and repeatedly won our re-competes. But my most satisfying accomplishments in those many years was to persuade three young women to focus on getting married instead of pursuing a career. I would ask them, “What do you want out of life?” And after they gave me the standard feminist mantra of career advancement, I would ask them, if they ever thought of marriage and children. Now I was an older, married man with three daughters of my own and they knew I loved my wife and children. They all answered of course. So then I would follow up with, “then why are you wasting your time pursuing a career instead of what you really want, because from what I was seeing the women who did that ended up alone, living with their cats.” All of them ended up getting married very soon and quit their jobs. One of them, the one that gave me the most pushback, tracked me down to show me her engagement ring. They just needed someone to break the feminist spell that was destroying their lives.

Expand full comment
Spouting Thomas's avatar

Thanks for citing the stat about the US being #1 in the world for single-parent households. I think every conversation on this topic needs to begin with this point. Maybe there's little hope of being best in the world, but I don't have much patience for people saying there is nothing that can be done. Can we at least aspire to second-worst? Is that really aiming too high?

On reflection, this statistic is really quite remarkable. We've been used to hearing, for at least my entire life, that the US is especially bad according to this or that social metric. But "especially bad" almost always means "one of the worst, if not THE worst, rich nation, or big nation."

For example, we're an extraordinarily obese country, but apparently only #11 in the world, after 10 tiny Pacific nations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_obesity_rate

It's remarkable, and disheartening, that in all the world's diversity we can't find a failed state nor a decaying empire nor a feminist social democracy nor a traditionally matrilocal society that underperforms us here.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts