Welcome back to the Masculinist, the monthly newsletter about the intersection of masculinity and Christianity. How Many People Are Saved? Very often the actions we take in life are predicated on implicit answers to questions we never explicitly considered.
Thank you for linking to this older article. Your critique of Deneen is interesting. You're right that to close the door on replacing or reforming liberalism doesn't make sense. Why are we even discussing the problem at all then?
But given the scope of liberalism's problems, and its powerful entrenchment across public and private spheres, a degree of "neo-tocquevillianism" seems like wisdom does it not? Pre-industrial society isn't coming back but I would argue that until men and women make the changes in their personal lives that bring about smaller forms of community within modern society, and lessen liberalism's hold on them, it will be next to impossible to challenge liberalism successfully. We have to start from a place of strength and individual, community-less people do not have much strength.